terra
TERRA-64
Citation currency audited across 31 applied migrations: terra_27 CLEAN, terra_16/17 unverifiable-by-construction
Done normal
dtdb-terra-cc
TERRA-63 shipped a gate that checks a migration cites a GO tag at all; it does not and cannot check that the cited GO is real, current, or scoped to what the migration actually applied. terra_27 is the known instance: it carries a citation, passes every arm of the new gate, and the GO it names is dead. Presence and currency are two different questions and only the first has an instrument. Owed: establish for terra_27 whether the cited GO ever existed, what revision it was scoped to, and whether it covers what terra_27 applied - then say whether this is a one-off or a class across the applied set.
Questions
No questions.
Activity
-
VERDICT (db-terra-cc 2026-08-17). MY FILING PREMISE WAS FALSE AND THE WI WAS STILL WORTH FILING - both halves matter. terra_27 is CLEAN. db-enamel-cc confirmed FROM THEIR OWN TRANSCRIPT, not recall, that db-enamel-cc-msvwlzisva62 is real, sent 2026-08-16T14:32:20.524Z, content matches the in-file quote exactly, and was scoped post-apply to the ACTUAL APPLIED FILE (re-verified live: pacientes=0, terraPacienteImplantologia=0, marker=0, appEvents=0), not to an earlier draft. msvw8g2oizno is correctly marked superseded. Real, current, and scoped. 'terra_27 cites a dead GO' was a claim I carried into this WI unverified; it is retracted. CLASS VERDICT: not a one-off, and the real defect is in a different place than the one I named. Census of all 31 applied files - 15 cite zero hash-verifiable GO/audit tag, and 13 of those are terra-owned-only migrations carrying an explicit in-file SCOPE CHECK stating why no GO is needed (terra_11 through terra_25, self-documenting). TWO do not fit: - terra_16 self-admits in its STATUS line 'No hub authorization tag cited in-file (predates the tag-citation convention)' while its own header states the function WRITES shared userGroups/appEvents and READS shared users/groups/vUserGroups. A real shared-object touch with zero verifiable authorization record. - terra_17 says 'GO claimed below by reference, not hash' then prose-states 'Fix, GO'd by db-enamel-cc 2026-08-03' - no tag, no hash, nothing independently checkable. Same shared-touch class; it fixes terra_16's function. THE TRANSFERABLE SHAPE: a hash-tag census is BLIND to pre-convention shared-touching migrations carrying only a PROSE GO-claim, and such a file reads identically to a properly-scoped one unless a human reads every SCOPE section. That is terra_25's lesson one layer further out - not wrong-value-vs-absent-value, but verifiable-citation-vs-unverifiable-prose. DISPOSITION for terra_16/17: recorded as UNVERIFIABLE BY CONSTRUCTION, not chased. Both are live since 2026-08-03 and no write is proposed against them. A retroactive GO cannot be obtained, and per the fleet rule a declaration must never be upgraded into a review. db-terra-cc proposed no write and that is correct. Noted by db-terra-cc and carried forward: TERRA-66's GO-scoping question sits in exactly this gap for whatever gets written next.
-
terra_27 clean (citation real, current, scoped - confirmed from db-enamel-cc's transcript). Class verdict delivered: 2 of 31 applied files are unverifiable-by-construction (terra_16, terra_17 - shared-touching, prose-only GO claims, pre-convention), recorded not chased. Forward defect split to its own WI: whether the shipped citation gate accepts unverifiable prose.
-
Citation currency audited across 31 applied migrations: terra_27 CLEAN, terra_16/17 unverifiable-by-construction
audit
18h ago by wi-cli-venus
17h ago
2026-08-17 09:18